top of page

The Many Forms of Frère Jacques


In this week's song I enlisted the help of a few of my teacher friends to expand my languages to include French and Spanish. We sang the very famous French song "Frère Jacques" in all four languages. You can watch that version below or you can skip past the video and see a comparison of this song in German and a few Germanic languages.


The standard "Hochdeutsch" version of this song looks like this:

Hochdeutsch

Bruder Jakob 2x Schläfst du noch? 2x Hörst du nicht die Glocken? 2x Ding dang dong 2x

In Schweizerdeutsch (Swiss German) it changes a bit. My comments on each line are in parentheses.

Brueder Jakob 2x

(Nothing special changes here except the added "e" in "Bruder".)

Schlafsch du no? 2x

(Notice the conjugation of "schlafen", which has "sch" instead of "st" and the "no" instead of "noch". It is pronounced like a German would say things, but the spelling clearly helps you get the pronunciation of the dialect.)

Ghörsch du nid die Glogge? 2x

(Half of the words in this phrase are different than the original. The word "hörst" has been changed to "Ghörsch". This is changed a couple of different ways. First it adds a "g" to the beginning of the word, which adds a harsher sound. Secondly, the conjugation for the "du-form" is the same as the previous line and has "sch" instead of "st".)

Bim bam bom. 2x

(I'm not entirely sure why this change happened, but it went from "ding, dang, dong" to "bim, bam, bom".)

Schweizerdeutsch (Swiss German)

Brueder Jakob 2x

Schlafsch du no? 2x

Ghörsch du nid die Glogge? 2x

Bim bam bom. 2x

If you look up the lyrics in Afrikaans, you will see some very strong similarities between the German and the English. I have a friend who posts things on Facebook in Afrikaans and I can actually understand what he is saying if I take the time to translate from Afrikanns to German. To my untrained eye, it looks like an essay written by a student who isn't sure what to do with the German language. See if you get the same vibe from the text below.

Afrikaans

Vader Jakob 2x Slaap jy nog? 2x Hoor hoe lui die kerkklok. 2x Ding dong del. 2x

If you go north of Germany to the Netherlands, you may hear a version that is very similar to the Afrikaans version, but you can see a bit of the Swiss showing through in the last line. Check out how similar the Dutch looks.

Niederländisch (Dutch)

Vader Jakob 2x Slaapt gij nog? 2x Alle klokken luiden 2x Bim bam bom 2x

Danish and Norwegian are also very similar looking to each other. Again, look at the last line. One has the German version and one has the Swiss version. The lyrics to each of those are found below.

Dänisch (Danish)

Mester Jakob 2x sover du? 2x Hører du ej klokken 2x Bim bam bum 2x

Norwegisch (Norwegian)

Fader Jakob 2x Sover du? 2x Hører du ej klokka? 2x Ding, Dang, Dong. 2x

If you are interested in reading more about this topic, you can find a long list of lyrics in a variety of different languages on the German Wikipedia article for this song.


Commenti


Learn German with Herr Antrim.jpeg

About the Author

Herr Antrim is a German teacher with over 10 years of teaching experience. In 2011 he started his successful YouTube Channel "Learn German with Herr Antrim". In 2013 he created this website to enhance the German language lessons he was providing on YouTube. He is now the author of his own e-book, "Beginner German with Herr Antrim". He has also been featured on numerous blogs and other sites. Find out more about Herr Antrim

  • Herr Antrim on YouTube
  • Herr Antrim on Twitter
  • Herr Antrim on Facebook
  • Herr Antrim on Instagram

Disclaimer: This website is not connected to Herr Antrim's work at Edwardsville High School. Everything that is on this website is about the YouTube channel "Learn German with Herr Antrim" and not the classes that he teaches at EHS. All opinions, ideas, and concepts on this website are property of Herr Antrim. 

Click to contact Herr Antrim via email

© 2018 Herr Antrim

Impressum

Learn German with Herr Antrim Voted #6 Best YouTube Channel for Learnig a Languge
Learn Germa with Herr Antrim Voted Top 15 Blogs for Learning German
bottom of page